John Cutler · 8 min read · Product Teams
TBM 438: The Right But Early Club
Read the original on cutlefish.substack.com →
TBM 438 explores the 'Right But Early Club' (RBEC), a concept for people who are right and early to spot problems but struggle to be heard or to translate insights into action. It examines the tension between warning early and being listened to, and why organizations often reward immediacy over foresight. The piece highlights identity clashes around competence and how to channel early signals into constructive, system-wide improvements.
Key Takeaways
- RBEC describes people who perceive issues early and accurately but feel unheard or undervalued, creating tension within teams.
- Organizations often reward quick fixes and addressing today’s problems over early detection; better signal detection, attention gating, and psychological safety are needed.
- A core identity clash exists around competence: foresight and vigilance versus speed and pragmatism, which can hinder addressing real issues.
- Leaders should create channels to surface early warnings, validate them, and translate them into action without punitive responses.
Excerpt
Life update! New job! Big shift! More here if you are curious. And more to come… I can’t get this out of my head. I was doing book research recently, and I learned about a “secret” group inside a company called the Right But Early Club. The basic idea of the Right But Early Club, if I understand correctly, is to serve as a support group (of sorts) for people who are “right” (we’ll discuss this more in a bit), but who tend to be “too early” when it comes to bringing up issues, calling out problems, offering solutions, etc.…